Stage391

Independent Third-Party Reproduction Verification & Assessment Adjudication Gate

第三者独立再現検証・外部評価判定ゲート

Stage391は、Stage390で準備された 第三者評価受入インターフェースの上に、 実際の第三者Submissionを 独立性、upstream binding、 reproduction state、 mismatch count、 assessment outcomeに基づいて Fail-Closedで検証・判定する executable adjudication layerです。

Current decision: third_party_submission_pending

Verification status: waiting_for_external_submission

Submission present: false  |  External assessment completed: false

Verified agreement: false  |  Verified disagreement: false

Stage390: third_party_assessment_ready  |  Stage389: dual_timestamp_pending

Stage388

Independent Assessment Readiness & Evidence Package Gate

Stage387までのPQC複数実装検証、 独立再検証、公開証拠、Fail-Closed、 再現性を変更せず、 外部研究者、OSSセキュリティコミュニティ、 セキュリティ専門家が独立評価できる 決定論的な第三者評価用証拠パッケージへ整理します。

評価範囲、脅威モデル、保証範囲、 非保証範囲、信頼境界、既知の制限、 正常系・異常系試験、Stage387 provenance、 SHA-256 evidence bindingをFail-Closedで固定します。

Current decision: independent_assessment_evidence_package_ready

External assessment completed: false  |  Formal certification: false

Stage387

PQC Multi-Implementation Interoperability & Verifier Independence Gate

Stage386までのPQC独立再検証・公開鍵バインディング・ 証拠可搬性を保持したまま、 同一のStage375 ML-DSA-65公開鍵、署名、署名対象、 contextを複数の独立した暗号実装で再検証し、 特定の検証器だけに依存しないことを確認します。

OpenSSLとCloudflare CIRCL v1.6.5が 同一の公開証拠に対して検証成功し、 両実装の結果が一致した場合にのみ Fail-ClosedでStage387成功を判定します。

Current decision: pqc_multi_implementation_interoperability_verified

Stage386

PQC Independent Re-verification, Public Key Binding & Evidence Portability Gate

Stage385までの検証履歴と公開ページ構造を保持したまま、 Stage375で実際に使用されたML-DSA-65公開鍵を 同一性確認した上で公開証拠へ結合し、 第三者による独立再検証可能性を確立します。

Stage386は新しいML-DSA鍵を生成せず、 Stage375で実際に使用された公開鍵の PEMおよびDER SHA-256を照合し、 署名、署名対象、実行receipt、algorithm、 contextを独立して再検証します。

Current decision: pqc_independent_reverification_verified

Stage385

Cryptographic Agility Inventory, PQC Migration Readiness & Algorithm Policy Enforcement Gate

Stage384までの検証履歴と公開ページ構造を保持したまま、 QSPで使用・参照される暗号資産を公開メタデータとして棚卸しし、 PQC移行準備性とアルゴリズムポリシーをFail-Closedで評価します。

Stage385は秘密鍵を収集・公開せず、 自動鍵生成、自動鍵ローテーション、 自動アルゴリズム置換、正式承認の自動発行も行いません。

Current decision: cryptographic_inventory_incomplete

Stage384

Continuous Trust-State Reverification & Change Invalidation Gate

Stage383までの検証履歴と公開ページ構造を保持したまま、 固定された信頼状態ベースラインと現在の監視対象を比較し、 変更、再検証要求、適格性無効化をFail-Closedで判定します。

Stage384は、正式承認や証明書を自動発行しません。 定期、Push、手動実行による継続再検証を提供しますが、 無停止のリアルタイム監視は主張しません。

Current decision: continuous_trust_state_verified_upstream_pending

Stage382

Upstream Finalization Recovery & Policy Activation Gate

Stage381までのクロスプラットフォーム決定論的再検証を保持したまま、 Stage377の二重タイムスタンプ最終承認条件を、 バージョン固定されたポリシープロファイルへ結合します。

Stage377が完了した後は、Stage378、Stage379、Stage380、 Stage381の順序で再検証することを要求します。 未完了の上流結果を自動的に完了扱いすることはありません。

Current decision: policy_bound_final_acceptance_pending

Stage377 verified proof count: 1 / Critical failures: 0

Stage376

Production Dual-Timestamp Verification & Superseding Final Acceptance Gate

Stage375の量子安全二重署名検証を継承し、 Stage360の正規化された対象に対して RFC3161とOpenTimestampsの二重タイムスタンプ検証を行います。 両方の外部証明が同一対象に対して独立に検証された場合のみ、 Stage372の履歴を変更せず、新しい有効な最終承認状態を成立させます。

Overview

Stage330 does not replace Stage329. It extends the Stage329 audit submission package by adding automatic SHA256 evidence hash generation.

AI主張
↓
再現証拠
↓
Stage328 Evidence Match Gate
↓
受け入れ / 保留 / reject
↓
Stage329 Signed Audit Report

Stage327 + Stage328 Integrated Builder

Input AI vulnerability claims and reproduction evidence, generate structured Stage327 JSON, and perform Stage328 gate verification.

AI脆弱性主張

再現証拠

Open Stage329 Audit Report

生成されたStage328 JSON

Generated JSON appears here.

Stage328 Gate判定

Gate decision appears here.
{}

Stage329監査提出レイヤー

After generating the Stage328 decision, Stage329 converts it into an audit package: JSON, HTML, signature, hash, and verification instructions.

Stage329 Audit Report Audit JSON Audit Signature Verify Instructions

判定ルール

受け入れ: all checks are true

保留: target/evidence exist but SHA256 or signature missing

reject: target mismatch or evidence missing

公開検証ファイル

Japanese Page English Page Schema JSON Example JSON Proof Viewer Stage328 Audit Report Audit History JSON Third-Party Verification Guide

Stage330 Evidence Hash Auto Builder

Stage330 adds automatic SHA256 hash generation to the Stage329 audit submission workflow. It reads evidence files, generates a SHA256 map, creates hash_manifest.json, and prepares reproduction_evidence.json for the Stage328 Evidence Match Gate.

prompt.txt
response.txt
run.log
↓
Automatic SHA256 Generation
↓
hash_manifest.json
↓
hash_manifest.sha256
↓
reproduction_evidence.json
↓
Stage328 Evidence Match Gate
↓
Stage329 Audit Submission Package
  

Generated Stage330 Files

Stage331 Execution Integrity

Stage331 extends Stage330 by binding evidence files into a single execution session.

prompt.txt
response.txt
run.log
↓
Execution Session Binding
↓
session_id
created_at
evidence_order
evidence_count
sha256_map
↓
execution_session.json
↓
Execution Integrity Verification

Stage331 verifies not only file integrity, but whether the evidence files belong to the same execution session.

What Stage330 Adds

Before Stage330 After Stage330
SHA256 map was manually written SHA256 map is automatically generated
Risk of copy mistakes Lower risk of human error
Audit package starts after hashes exist Audit package includes the hash generation layer

Stage332: Signed Execution Session

Stage332 extends Stage331 by cryptographically signing the execution session. The audit target is execution_session.json.

The execution session becomes signed audit evidence through GPG signature, Sigstore bundle, and public verification.

This stage proves who generated the execution evidence, whether the evidence was modified, and whether the execution session can be independently verified.

Meaning: this proves who generated the execution session and turns execution evidence into signed audit evidence.

Stage333 Transparency Log

Stage333 extends Stage332 by recording the signed execution session into an append-only transparency log.

Stage332 → Stage333

execution_session.json
↓
GPG / Sigstore signature
↓
transparency-log.json
↓
previous_hash chain
↓
public audit timeline

Latest Transparency Log Entry

Loading transparency log...

View Transparency Timeline

View Transparency Log JSON

Verification Instructions

Stage334 AI Vulnerability Watch Atlas + Stage335 Safe AI Vulnerability Intelligence Fetcher

Stage334 extends Stage333 by adding a safe AI vulnerability watch system. It organizes AI failure patterns from security sources into a public audit atlas.

Stage333 → Stage334

Stage333 Transparency Log
↓
signed evidence history
↓
AI vulnerability source watch
↓
AI vulnerability atlas
↓
safe reproduction planning

Safety Boundary

Latest Watch Summary

Loading Stage334 watch summary...

View Stage334 Intelligence Page

View AI Vulnerability Atlas JSON

View Watch Summary JSON

Stage335 Safe AI Vulnerability Intelligence Fetcher

Stage335 extends Stage334 by collecting safe AI vulnerability intelligence metadata. Dangerous prompts, exploit code, weaponized payloads, and attack automation are not published.

Stage334 → Stage335

Stage334 AI Vulnerability Watch Atlas
↓
safe AI risk categories
↓
Stage335 Safe Metadata Fetcher
↓
safe intelligence feed
↓
collection transparency log
↓
private internal Runner preparation

Public / Private Separation

Latest Stage335 Summary

Loading Stage335 summary...

View Stage335 Page

View Safe Intelligence Feed

View Collection Transparency Log

Stage336: Safe Live Intelligence Fetcher

Stage336 extends Stage335 by adding live public AI/security intelligence metadata. This is added after the Stage335 Safe AI Vulnerability Intelligence Fetcher section, preserving all previous Stage329–Stage335 functions.

Stage335 → Stage336

Stage335 Safe Intelligence Fetcher
↓
Safe intelligence feed
↓
Collection transparency log
↓
Stage336 Safe Live Intelligence Fetcher
↓
Live public metadata collection
↓
Audit metadata connected to Stage335

Open Stage336 Live Intelligence Live Intelligence JSON Stage336 Audit Session JSON

Stage338: Behavior Decision Engine

Stage337 adds safe reproduction templates for AI vulnerability verification. This stage does not include attack code, exploit payloads, bypass steps, or automated attack logic.

Template Flow

Template Library

safe_reproduction_templates.json

Meaning

Stage336 collected safe intelligence metadata. Stage337 adds the missing safe template layer for future behavior matching.

Stage338: Behavior Decision Engine

Stage338 adds behavior decision capability to the existing safe reproduction template library.

Stage337 defined the rulebook. Stage338 compares expected behavior with actual behavior and returns a decision.

Public output: behavior_decision.json

This stage does not publish attack code, dangerous prompts, payloads, or exploit automation.

Stage339: Unified QSP Behavior Policy Action Gate

Stage339 integrates earlier QSP decision capabilities into the Stage338 behavior decision layer.

This stage connects behavior decision, trust score, evidence match, signature status, public policy, action mapping, and fail-closed behavior.

Public policy: unified_qsp_policy.json

Public input: unified_qsp_input.json

Public result: unified_qsp_behavior_policy_action_result.json

Stage339 is fail-closed. If behavior is unknown, evidence is insufficient, signature verification fails, or policy evaluation errors, the system rejects or blocks.

This stage does not publish attack code, dangerous prompts, payloads, bypass steps, or exploit automation.

Stage339: Deterministic Protocol Proof

Stage339 now verifies deterministic protocol behavior.

The same canonical input is evaluated twice. If both evaluations produce the same canonical decision hash, deterministic_protocol.same_input_same_output becomes true.

This strengthens the Stage284 integration by proving that the same input produces the same policy action output.

Stage340: Unified Verification Session Manifest

Stage340 connects the Stage254 session manifest concept to the Stage339 unified QSP behavior policy action result.

This stage binds one complete verification result into a session manifest.

Public session result: qsp_session_result.json

Public session manifest: session_manifest.json

Public local witness: local_witness.json

Public anchor receipt: session_anchor_receipt.json

Stage340 does not publish private keys, attack code, dangerous prompts, exploit payloads, or automated attack logic.

Stage341: Signed Verification Session Manifest

Stage341 signs the Stage340 session_manifest.json and turns it into signed verification session evidence.

This stage adds GPG signature, Ed25519 witness signature, and Sigstore bundle verification.

Signed manifest: signed_session_manifest.json

Signature manifest: session_signature_manifest.json

GPG signature: session_manifest.json.gpg.asc

Ed25519 witness signature: session_manifest.ed25519.sig

Ed25519 witness public key: stage341_ed25519_witness.pub

Sigstore bundle: session_manifest.sigstore.bundle

Verification succeeded for GPG, Ed25519 witness, and Sigstore.

Stage341 does not publish private keys, attack code, dangerous prompts, exploit payloads, or automated attack logic.

Stage342: External Anchor Layer

Stage342 extends Stage341 by adding external anchoring for the signed verification session manifest.

This stage adds checkpoint witness, GitHub Actions anchor support, OpenTimestamps support, and an external anchor receipt.

External anchor receipt: external_anchor_receipt.json

GitHub Actions anchor intent: github_actions_anchor_intent.json

Checkpoint witness: checkpoint_witness.json

Checkpoint public key: stage342_checkpoint_witness.pub

Checkpoint signature: session_manifest.checkpoint.sig

Stage342 does not publish private keys, attack code, dangerous prompts, exploit payloads, or automated attack logic.

Stage343: Verified External Anchor Layer

Stage343 verifies the external anchor layer created in Stage342.

This stage checks hash binding, checkpoint witness, Ed25519 witness, GPG signature, Sigstore bundle, OpenTimestamps status, and GitHub Actions anchor intent.

Independent verification report: independent_verification_report.json

Verification summary: verification_summary.txt

Stage343 does not publish private keys, attack code, dangerous prompts, exploit payloads, or automated attack logic.

Stage344: Verified GitHub Artifact Layer

Stage344 verifies GitHub Actions run evidence and connects it to the Stage343 independent verification report.

This stage prepares GitHub Actions artifact download verification and checks the latest workflow run, SHA256 binding, and previous independent verification result.

GitHub artifact verification report: github_artifact_verification_report.json

GitHub artifact verification summary: github_artifact_verification_summary.txt

Stage344 does not publish private keys, attack code, dangerous prompts, exploit payloads, or automated attack logic.

Stage345: Artifact Download Verification Engine

Stage345 extends Stage344 by turning GitHub artifact verification readiness into actual artifact download verification.

This stage downloads the GitHub Actions artifact, verifies SHA256 binding, checks the session manifest, checks the GitHub run binding, and produces an accept / reject verification report.

Artifact download verification report: artifact_download_verification_report.json

Artifact download verification summary: artifact_download_verification_summary.txt

Stage345 does not publish private keys, attack code, dangerous prompts, exploit payloads, or automated attack logic.

Stage346: Multi-Artifact Verification Layer

Stage346 extends Stage345 by verifying multiple public verification artifacts as one connected evidence set.

This stage checks the session manifest, signed session manifest, external anchor receipt, Stage343 independent verification report, Stage344 GitHub artifact verification report, and Stage345 artifact download verification report.

Multi-artifact verification report: multi_artifact_verification_report.json

Multi-artifact verification summary: multi_artifact_verification_summary.txt

Stage346 does not publish private keys, attack code, dangerous prompts, exploit payloads, or automated attack logic.

Stage347: Quantum-Safe Behavior Template Layer

Stage347 extends Stage346 by adding PQC/QKD behavior templates to the multi-artifact verification layer. It connects safe metadata from quantum-safe implementation history to the current QSP evidence verification rail.

Quantum-Safe Behavior Templates
Quantum-Safe Behavior Input
Quantum-Safe Behavior Decision

Stage348: Quantum-Safe Evidence Binding Schema Layer

Stage348 extends Stage347 by binding PQC/QKD evidence metadata to a shared schema, SHA256 hashes, Git commit metadata, and signature presence checks.

Quantum-Safe Evidence Schema
Quantum Execution Evidence
Quantum Schema Validation Result
Quantum Evidence Binding Result

Stage349: SLSA/SBOM Evidence Bridge Layer

Stage349 extends Stage348 by connecting SLSA, SBOM, provenance, artifact attestation, policy gate, and Ed25519 review evidence metadata to the REMEDA/QSP evidence verification rail.

SLSA/SBOM Evidence Schema
SLSA/SBOM Evidence Input
SLSA/SBOM Bridge Result

Stage350: Supply-Chain Evidence Enforcement Session Layer

Stage350 upgrades the Stage349 bridge result into an enforceable supply-chain evidence session.

Public evidence: enforcement_session.json / stage350-transparency-log.json

Stage351: Hybrid Enforcement Signature Manifest Layer

Stage351 extends Stage350 by binding the enforcement session, CI/local execution context, Sigstore OIDC requirements, and PQC ML-DSA intent into one hybrid signature manifest.

Public evidence: stage351_signature_manifest.json

Stage352: Hybrid Signature Manifest Verification Layer

Stage352 verifies the Stage351 hybrid signature manifest against the Stage350 enforcement session.

Public evidence: stage352_signature_manifest_verification.json

Stage353: Verification Transparency Chain Layer

Stage353 records the Stage352 signature-manifest verification result into a transparency chain.

Public evidence: stage353_verification_transparency_result.json / stage353_verification_transparency_chain.json / stage353_verification_transparency_summary.txt

Stage354: Signature Key Rotation Ledger Layer

Stage354 initializes a signature key rotation ledger with Stage178 Assumption / Threat Model / Guarantee binding. It records GPG, Sigstore OIDC, Ed25519, and PQC ML-DSA key lifecycle states without publishing private keys or fake active PQC key claims.

Stage355: Signature Key Status Verification & Revocation Enforcement Layer

Stage355 extends Stage354 by reading the signature key rotation ledger, verifying key status records, checking revocation safety, preserving PQC ML-DSA as intent_only unless real proof exists, and binding the Stage354 entry_hash as the Stage355 previous_hash.

Stage356: Runtime Verification & Fail-Closed Execution Gate

Stage356 extends Stage355 by binding the Stage355 integrity result into a runtime verification gate. If Stage355 is missing, rejected, inconsistent, or contains violations, the runtime decision becomes block. Local execution is marked as warn, while CI execution can be allowed only when the required checks pass.

Stage357: Runtime Context Action & Isolation Enforcer

Stage357 extends Stage356 by mapping runtime decisions into defensive actions. allow continues execution, warn isolates risky capabilities and continues safely, and block terminates execution. Stage357 binds the Stage356 receipt_sha256 as previous_hash and publishes metadata-only action receipts without exposing private runners, secrets, payloads, or exploit code.

Stage358: Signing-Time Validity Enforcement Layer

Stage358 extends Stage357 by enforcing temporal validity between signing_time and key lifecycle windows. It checks valid_from <= signing_time <= valid_until and signing_time < revoked_at when revocation metadata exists. Stage358 binds the Stage357 action receipt SHA256 as previous_hash and publishes metadata-only temporal validation without claiming real GPG, Sigstore, Rekor, or PQC signature verification.

Stage359: Real Public Key Fingerprint Validation Layer

Stage359 extends Stage358 by binding the Stage358 temporal validity result into public-key fingerprint validation. It checks public_key_fingerprint presence and SHA256 format, validates key_id / algorithm / validity-window consistency, preserves PQC ML-DSA as intent_only, and records readiness for future external timestamp and revocation proof verification without exposing private keys or real key material.

Stage360: External Timestamp Proof Binding Layer

Stage360 extends Stage359 by binding the Stage359 public-key fingerprint result into external timestamp proof metadata. It creates a timestamp target SHA256, records OpenTimestamps and RFC3161 proof readiness, returns pending_timestamp_proof when real external proof is not present, and blocks fake verified timestamp claims. Stage360 does not claim real OTS or RFC3161 verification.

Stage361: Revocation Proof Injection Gate

Stage361 extends Stage360 by adding a revocation proof injection gate to the QSP evidence rail.

Stage360 binds the Stage359 public key fingerprint result into external timestamp proof metadata. Stage361 adds the next missing verification layer: whether the related key or certificate is revoked.

Stage361 Revocation Proof Injection Result JSON
Stage361 Summary TXT

Stage362: Asynchronous Proof Promotion Gate

Stage362 extends Stage361 by adding an asynchronous proof promotion gate. It does not treat pending proof as acceptance. It decides whether pending timestamp or revocation proof can be promoted after new proof metadata is added.

Stage361 created the revocation proof receiver. Stage362 reviews whether that pending proof may be promoted, kept pending, rejected, or blocked.

Stage362 Promotion Request JSON
Stage362 Promotion Result JSON
Stage362 Summary TXT

Stage363: External Timestamp Proof Verification Gate

Stage363 extends Stage362 by adding an external timestamp proof verification gate for OpenTimestamps and RFC3161. It focuses on timestamp proof verification and does not verify OCSP or CRL revocation status.

Stage360 created the external timestamp proof binding receiver. Stage362 created the asynchronous proof promotion gate. Stage363 checks whether external timestamp proof metadata can support timestamp verification.

Stage363 Timestamp Proof Input JSON
Stage363 Timestamp Verification Result JSON
Stage363 Summary TXT

Stage364: Real Timestamp Proof Injection & Promotion Engine

Stage364 extends Stage363 by adding a real timestamp proof injection and promotion engine for OpenTimestamps and RFC3161. It reviews whether timestamp_pending can be promoted to timestamp_verified.

Stage363 created the external timestamp proof verification gate. Stage364 injects real timestamp verification evidence and checks whether the target hash matches the Stage360 timestamp target.

Stage364 Timestamp Proof Injection Input JSON
Stage364 Timestamp Promotion Result JSON
Stage364 Summary TXT

Stage365: Verified Timestamp Promotion Test Harness

Stage365 extends Stage364 by adding a safe timestamp promotion test harness with a fake-verified claim guard. It does not convert production evidence to timestamp_verified.

Stage365 tests whether the timestamp promotion path is safe before connecting a real OpenTimestamps or RFC3161 verifier adapter.

Stage365 Timestamp Promotion Test Cases JSON
Stage365 Test Result JSON
Stage365 Summary TXT

Stage366: Real OpenTimestamps / RFC3161 Verifier Adapter

Stage366 extends Stage365 by adding a real OpenTimestamps / RFC3161 verifier adapter. It does not treat Stage365 simulation as production timestamp verification.

Stage365 safely tested the timestamp promotion path. Stage366 connects that safe test result to real verifier output readiness.

Stage366 Verifier Adapter Input JSON
Stage366 Verifier Adapter Result JSON
Stage366 Summary TXT

Stage367: Production Timestamp Verification Activation Gate

Stage367 extends Stage366 by adding a production timestamp verification activation gate for OpenTimestamps / RFC3161. It can move verifier_pending to timestamp_verified only when real verifier output exists.

Stage366 created the real verifier adapter. Stage367 activates production verification with matching Stage360 target hash and verified output evidence.

Stage367 Activation Input JSON
Stage367 Activation Result JSON
Stage367 Summary TXT

Stage368: Production Timestamp Verification Receipt Layer

Stage368 extends Stage367 by adding a production timestamp verification receipt layer for OpenTimestamps / RFC3161. It records real verification command receipts as metadata.

Stage367 created the activation gate. Stage368 fixes command receipt metadata such as exit code, output SHA256, and verified target hash.

Stage368 Receipt Input JSON
Stage368 Receipt Result JSON
Stage368 Summary TXT

Stage369: Real Timestamp Verifier Runner with Production Receipt Generation

Stage369 extends Stage368 by adding a real timestamp verifier runner for OpenTimestamps / RFC3161. It runs or prepares verifier commands and converts their outputs into metadata receipts.

Stage368 created the receipt layer. Stage369 generates production receipt metadata, but it does not final-accept timestamp_verified.

Stage369 Runner Input JSON
Stage369 Runner Result JSON
Stage369 Summary TXT

Stage370: Runner Safety Brake Test Gate

Stage370 extends Stage369 by adding a runner safety brake test gate. It verifies that the timestamp runner fails safely before real timestamp verification success is accepted.

Stage369 created the real timestamp verifier runner. Stage370 confirms that bad commands, incomplete metadata, fake verified claims, and raw timestamp binary references do not pass.

Stage370 Safety Test Input JSON
Stage370 Safety Test Result JSON
Stage370 Summary TXT

Stage371: Real Timestamp First Successful Receipt Gate

Stage371 extends Stage370 by adding a real timestamp first successful receipt gate for OpenTimestamps / RFC3161. It can generate the first successful timestamp receipt only after the Stage370 safety brake tests pass.

Stage370 confirmed that bad commands, incomplete metadata, fake verified claims, and raw timestamp binary references do not pass. Stage371 uses that safety result before allowing any first successful receipt generation.

Stage371 First Receipt Input JSON
Stage371 First Receipt Result JSON
Stage371 Summary TXT

Stage372: Timestamp Verification Final Acceptance Gate

Stage372 extends Stage371 by adding the final timestamp verification acceptance gate. It reviews the Stage371 first receipt and decides whether timestamp verification can be finally accepted.

Stage371 can generate the first successful timestamp receipt. Stage372 is the first layer that may set timestamp_verified: true, but only when the Stage371 receipt is complete and consistent.

Stage372 Final Acceptance Result JSON
Stage372 Final Acceptance Manifest JSON
Stage372 Summary TXT

Stage373: Final Acceptance Attestation & External Transparency Binding Gate

Stage373 extends Stage372 by binding the Stage372 final-acceptance result and manifest into one canonical attestation.

Stage373 does not repeat OpenTimestamps or RFC3161 verification. It validates the Stage372 result and manifest hashes, generates a shared binding hash, and prepares external Sigstore, Rekor, and optional standalone ML-DSA verification.

Stage372 to Stage373

Stage372 final acceptance result
+ Stage372 final acceptance manifest

independent SHA256 validation

canonical Stage372 binding

Stage373 final acceptance attestation

Sigstore signature verification
+ Rekor inclusion-proof verification
+ optional standalone ML-DSA verification

Current Initial State

Stage373 never converts the current pending Stage372 result into a verified final acceptance.

External Transparency Checks

Safety Boundary

Stage373 External Transparency Input JSON
Stage373 Final Acceptance Attestation JSON
Stage373 External Transparency Binding Result JSON
Stage373 Summary TXT

Stage374: Production Sigstore Signing & Rekor Inclusion Verification Gate

Stage374 extends Stage373 by performing production Sigstore signing and Rekor transparency-log inclusion verification for the Stage373 final-acceptance attestation.

Stage373 prepared the attestation and external verification receiver. Stage374 uses GitHub Actions OIDC, Cosign, and a Sigstore bundle to produce real external verification evidence.

Stage373 to Stage374

Stage373 attestation

SHA256 revalidation

GitHub Actions OIDC

Cosign sign-blob

Sigstore bundle

identity and issuer verification

Rekor inclusion verification

external transparency binding result

Current Initial State

After complete Sigstore and Rekor verification, while Stage372 remains pending, the correct decision becomes pending_state_transparency_bound.

Current Verified State

This means that the Stage372 pending state was successfully signed through GitHub Actions OIDC and bound to the external Sigstore/Rekor transparency infrastructure. It does not mean that Stage372 timestamp final acceptance has completed.

Verification Requirements

Safety Boundary

Stage374 Production Input JSON
Stage374 Cosign Execution Receipt JSON
Stage374 Rekor Inclusion Receipt JSON
Stage374 External Binding Result JSON
Stage374 Summary TXT

Stage375: Production ML-DSA-65 Dual-Signature Verification & Downgrade Prevention Gate

Stage375 extends Stage374 by adding real ML-DSA-65 signing and verification for the same Stage373 attestation blob already verified through Sigstore, Cosign, GitHub Actions OIDC, and Rekor.

Stage374 to Stage375

Stage374 verified Sigstore/Rekor evidence

Stage373 attestation blob SHA256 validation

ML-DSA-65 signing

ML-DSA-65 signature verification

Sigstore and ML-DSA target comparison

fail-closed downgrade prevention

Current Initial State

Successful State

Current Verified State

The Stage374 Sigstore/Rekor signature and the Stage375 ML-DSA-65 signature were verified against the same Stage373 attestation blob. The ML-DSA private key was not published.

Downgrade Prevention

When pqc_required is enabled, a valid Sigstore signature alone is not sufficient. A missing, invalid, removed, or mismatched ML-DSA-65 signature fails closed.

Safety Boundary

Stage375 ML-DSA-65 Input JSON
Stage375 ML-DSA-65 Public Key
Stage375 ML-DSA-65 Execution Receipt
Stage375 Dual-Signature Result
Stage375 Summary

Stage376: Production Dual-Timestamp Verification & Superseding Final Acceptance Gate

Stage376 extends Stage375 by applying two independent external timestamp verification methods—RFC3161 and OpenTimestamps—to the canonical Stage360 timestamp target.

Stage376 does not rewrite the historic Stage372 record. Stage372 remains preserved as final_acceptance_pending. Stage376 creates a new effective final-acceptance state only after both timestamp verification methods are independently verified against the same canonical target.

Stage375 to Stage376

Stage375 quantum-safe dual-signature verification
↓
Stage360 canonical timestamp target validation
↓
RFC3161 production timestamp verification
+
OpenTimestamps public-anchor verification
↓
independent verification receipt validation
↓
dual-timestamp target comparison
↓
superseding final acceptance
↓
maximum timestamp assurance
  

Canonical Timestamp Target

The timestamp target is reconstructed from the Stage360 canonical timestamp-binding object.

052c8f0283110e405443d56f2396c52a8486e7a70a489f831af107dad73ab1b5

Stage375 Prerequisite State

Current Production State

Stage376 is currently in a safe pending state. The canonical Stage360 timestamp target and the fixed production workflow inputs have been prepared, but neither RFC3161 nor OpenTimestamps production verification has completed.

Stage376 must not claim timestamp verification, external final acceptance, or maximum timestamp assurance until independently valid RFC3161 and OpenTimestamps verification receipts are imported and validated against the same Stage360 target.

RFC3161 Production Verification

Stage376 is designed to generate an RFC3161 timestamp request for the canonical Stage360 target, submit it to a configured Timestamp Authority, receive the timestamp response, and verify the response cryptographically with OpenSSL.

The current public RFC3161 receipt is an initial safety receipt. Its execution status is not_executed, and the TSA URL, request hash, response hash, timestamp-token hash, message imprint, generation time, verification exit code, TSA signature result, and certificate-chain result have not yet been recorded.

RFC3161 verification may be marked as successful only after a fixed GitHub Actions workflow produces a complete metadata receipt whose target hash matches the canonical Stage360 target.

OpenTimestamps Verification

OpenTimestamps is the second independent timestamp method required by the Stage376 dual-timestamp policy.

Until an OpenTimestamps proof is independently verified against the same Stage360 target and a confirmed public anchor is recorded, Stage376 remains in a partial verification state.

Final Acceptance Rule

Stage376 may return dual_timestamp_final_acceptance_verified only when every required condition below is satisfied.

Successful Final State

Only after all acceptance conditions pass may Stage376 publish the following state:

decision: dual_timestamp_final_acceptance_verified
rfc3161_verified: true
opentimestamps_verified: true
dual_timestamp_target_matches: true
effective_final_acceptance: true
timestamp_verified: true
maximum_timestamp_assurance: true
  

Historic Stage372 Preservation

Stage376 does not alter or overwrite Stage372. Instead, it preserves Stage372 as historical evidence and creates a later superseding operational state after stronger external proof requirements are satisfied.

Fail-Closed Enforcement

Publication Boundary

Public Evidence

Stage376 Stage360 Timestamp Target JSON
Stage376 Dual-Timestamp Final Acceptance Input JSON
Stage376 RFC3161 Verification Receipt JSON
Stage376 OpenTimestamps Verification Receipt JSON

Current Meaning

Stage376 currently proves that the dual-timestamp verification target, policy, fixed execution mode, safety boundaries, and initial metadata receivers have been prepared.

The historic Stage372 evidence remains preserved without modification. Stage376 is designed to create a later superseding effective state rather than rewriting the original Stage372 record.

It does not yet prove successful RFC3161 verification, OpenTimestamps verification, dual-timestamp final acceptance, or maximum timestamp assurance.

Stage376 prepares a cryptographically verifiable superseding final acceptance state while preserving the complete historical Stage372 evidence unchanged.

Stage377

Production Dual-Timestamp Finalization and Superseding Final Acceptance Gate

Stage377 adds production dual-timestamp finalization directly on top of Stage376.

Stage376 prepared the fixed Stage360 timestamp target, dual-timestamp verification policy, Fail-Closed requirements, publication boundary, and initial metadata receipt structures.

Stage377 connects that prepared state to production RFC3161 and OpenTimestamps verification receipts.

Stage377 does not remove, reorganize, replace, or rewrite the Stage376 page. The complete Stage376 page remains preserved before this Stage377 section.

Stage377 Purpose

Stage377 establishes a later superseding effective final acceptance only when RFC3161 and OpenTimestamps independently verify the same fixed Stage360 target.

Stage376 Prepared Dual-Timestamp State
↓
Production RFC3161 Verification
+
Production OpenTimestamps Verification
↓
Same Stage360 Target Confirmation
↓
Stage377 Dual-Timestamp Finalization Gate
↓
Verified / Pending / Block

Current Fail-Closed State

Decision: timestamp_finalization_pending

RFC3161 Verified: False
OpenTimestamps Verified: False
Effective Final Acceptance: False
Maximum Timestamp Assurance: False

This is the correct initial state. Stage377 must not claim successful dual-timestamp final acceptance until both independent external verification receipts satisfy every required condition.

Stage377 Adds

Production RFC3161 Verification

The RFC3161 workflow creates a timestamp request for the fixed canonical Stage360 target.

The returned timestamp response is checked with OpenSSL. Stage377 requires verification of the target message imprint, TSA signature, certificate chain, generation time, and fixed target SHA256.

Raw TSQ, TSR, RFC3161 token, and certificate-bundle files remain outside the public docs directory. Only a metadata verification receipt may be published.

Production OpenTimestamps Verification

The OpenTimestamps workflow creates a proof for the same fixed Stage360 target.

A newly created OpenTimestamps proof may remain pending while waiting for confirmation by a public blockchain anchor. Stage377 preserves that waiting state and does not convert it into a false success.

The proof is not accepted as verified until its target hash, public anchor, anchor reference, and verified time satisfy the Stage377 policy.

Stage377 Acceptance Conditions

Requirement Mandatory condition
Stage376 prerequisite Required Stage376 result and fixed hash are valid
Historic Stage372 evidence Fixed Stage372 evidence hash remains unchanged
RFC3161 target Message imprint matches the fixed Stage360 target
RFC3161 signature TSA signature verification succeeds
RFC3161 certificate TSA certificate-chain verification succeeds
OpenTimestamps target Proof target matches the fixed Stage360 target
OpenTimestamps anchor Public anchor and verified time are confirmed
Common target Both receipts bind to the same Stage360 SHA256
Verified proof count Two independent timestamp proofs are verified
Publication boundary No raw proof or private material exists under docs

Stage377 Decisions

Decision Meaning
timestamp_finalization_pending Neither external timestamp system has completed all final verification requirements.
rfc3161_verified_opentimestamps_pending RFC3161 is verified, but OpenTimestamps remains pending.
opentimestamps_verified_rfc3161_pending OpenTimestamps is verified, but RFC3161 remains pending.
dual_timestamp_final_acceptance_verified Both independent proofs verified the same Stage360 target and the superseding effective final-acceptance state was established.
block A prerequisite, required hash, proof, claim, consistency rule, or publication boundary failed.

Fail-Closed Enforcement

Fixed Hash Bindings

Stage376 result SHA256
32ff58a1f4d5837518226eee70b32833a8147617df3142ff2f641eca3f116138

Stage360 target SHA256
052c8f0283110e405443d56f2396c52a8486e7a70a489f831af107dad73ab1b5

Historic Stage372 result SHA256
ef1847f09c7862d271d71e548f403f75c91b93b2ffc21dec6016f53e0db7c3aa

Public Stage377 Evidence

Stage377 GitHub Actions

Publication Boundary

Historic Preservation

Stage377 does not alter or overwrite Stage372 or Stage376. It preserves both earlier stages as historical evidence.

Stage377 creates a later superseding operational state only after the stronger dual-timestamp requirements are satisfied. It does not rewrite an earlier final-acceptance record.

Current Meaning

Stage377 currently proves that the production dual-timestamp workflows, fixed hash bindings, Fail-Closed finalization engine, metadata receipt structures, and publication boundary have been prepared.

The current initial result remains timestamp_finalization_pending.

Stage377 therefore does not yet claim successful RFC3161 verification, successful OpenTimestamps verification, dual-timestamp final acceptance, or maximum timestamp assurance.

After both independent systems verify the same fixed Stage360 target, Stage377 can establish the later superseding effective final-acceptance state.

License: MIT License

\n\n

Stage378: QKD Safety Metadata Binding & Evidence Classification Gate

Stage378 extends Stage377 by binding public QKD safety metadata to the validated Stage377 result hash.

It classifies evidence as metadata only, QKD simulator, controlled testbed, or physical QKD system, while verifying that no raw or derived QKD secret material is published.

Stage377 to Stage378

Stage377 dual-timestamp finalization result

Stage377 result SHA256 validation

previous_hash binding

QKD safety metadata validation

evidence classification

QKD evidence-level assignment

Stage378 decision

Current State

This is the expected Fail-Closed state. Stage378 does not convert an incomplete Stage377 result into a completed QKD metadata binding.

Evidence Classifications

QKD Evidence Levels

QBER Metadata

Stage378 does not hard-code one universal QBER threshold. It validates observed_qber, declared_qber_limit, qber_within_declared_limit, and limit_source.

Public Stage378 Evidence

Publication Boundary

Stage378 does not modify or overwrite Stage377.

License: MIT License

Stage379: Scoped Total Verification Acceptance Certificate & Pipeline Completion Gate

Stage379は、Stage377およびStage378までに積み上げた タイムスタンプ、QKD安全メタデータ、証拠区分、 ハッシュ連鎖、公開境界を、範囲を固定した一つの 総合検証結果へ統合します。

Current State

Stage379は、上流条件が未完了である間、 正式承認やパイプライン完了を主張しません。 これは意図されたFail-Closed状態です。

Public Stage379 Evidence

Stage379 does not overwrite Stage378.

License: MIT License

Stage380: Independent Verification Package Contract & Deterministic Offline Core Verifier

Stage380は、Stage379の固定された検証範囲を、 ネットワークを必要としない決定論的な独立検証パッケージとして 再検証します。

Current State

Stage380の内部パッケージ整合性は検証済みです。 ただしStage377、Stage378、Stage379の正式な上流条件が 未完了であるため、正式承認は主張しません。

Deterministic Offline Properties

Public Stage380 Evidence

Stage380 does not overwrite Stage379.

License: MIT License

Stage381: Cross-Platform Deterministic Reverification & Reproducibility Gate

Stage381は、同一のStage380検証入力を Ubuntu、Windows、macOSで実行し、 OSの違いによって検証判定が変化しないことを確認します。

Verified Cross-Platform Flow

Stage380 deterministic offline result

fixed canonicalization profile

Ubuntu reverification

Windows reverification

macOS reverification

comparison of required fields and hashes

Stage381 cross-platform decision

Successful Verification State

Common Canonical Result SHA-256

d248ee64a524cea14ecb1a7e75a977bc53a6a44ed98ff48ef1ca159932eed1d9

GitHub Actions Verification

Meaning of the Current Decision

Stage381のクロスプラットフォーム再現性は検証済みです。 ただし、Stage377からStage380までの上流正式承認条件が 未完了であるため、QSP全体の正式承認やパイプライン完了を 意味するものではありません。

Public Stage381 Evidence

Publication Boundary

Stage381 does not modify or overwrite Stage380.

License: MIT License

Stage382: Upstream Finalization Recovery & Policy Activation Gate

Stage382は、Stage377の二重タイムスタンプ最終承認条件を、 バージョン固定されたポリシープロファイルとSHA-256へ結合します。

Stage377からStage381までの既存結果を変更せず、 正しい回復順序と現在の待機状態を明示します。

Required Recovery Order

Stage377 dual-timestamp final acceptance

Stage378 QKD safety metadata rebinding

Stage379 scoped total verification

Stage380 deterministic offline verification

Stage381 cross-platform reverification

Stage382 policy-bound verification

Current State

これは意図されたFail-Closed待機状態です。 Stage377のOpenTimestamps検証が完了するまで、 Stage382は正式承認やパイプライン完了を主張しません。

Versioned Policy Profile

Policy Requirements

Public Stage382 Evidence

Formal-Acceptance Boundary

Publication Boundary

Stage382 does not modify or overwrite Stage381 or any earlier stage.

License: MIT License

Stage383: Policy-Bound Recovery Orchestration & Formal Acceptance Eligibility Gate

Stage383は、Stage377からStage382までの既存検証記録を 上書きせず、1つの決定論的リカバリーセッションへ結合します。

正式承認を自動発行するのではなく、 正式承認を発行できる条件がすべて満たされたかを Fail-Closedで判定します。

Required Recovery Order

Stage377 dual-timestamp final acceptance

Stage378 QKD safety metadata reverification

Stage379 scoped total verification

Stage380 deterministic offline verification

Stage381 cross-platform reverification

Stage382 policy-bound verification

Stage383 formal-acceptance eligibility decision

Current State

これは意図されたFail-Closed待機状態です。 Stage377のOpenTimestamps検証が完了するまで、 Stage383は正式承認適格性を成立させません。

Deterministic Recovery Session

Current recovery-session identifier:

stage383-66bce0a526782ef0e49221e70bcc939268f0d04e6e2e86e34aea9aed6caf5505

このIDは固定入力から決定論的に生成され、 実行時刻、乱数、ホスト名、ユーザー名、 ローカル絶対パスを判定材料に使用しません。

Eligibility and Issuance Boundary

formal_acceptance_eligibleformal_acceptance_issuedは別の状態です。 Stage383は適格性を検証しますが、 正式承認証明書を自動発行しません。

Verified Local State

Public Stage383 Evidence

Preservation Boundary

Stage383は、Stage377からStage382までの既存結果を 変更、削除、置換、上書きしません。

Publication Boundary

License: MIT License

Stage384: Continuous Trust-State Reverification & Change Invalidation Gate

Stage384は、Stage383の決定論的リカバリーセッションと 13個の監視対象を固定ベースラインとして保持し、 現在状態との差分を継続的に再検証します。

変更を検知した場合は、影響に応じて 再検証要求、正式承認適格性の無効化、 またはFail-Closedを成立させます。

Continuous Reverification Flow

Stage383 recovery session

Stage384 policy SHA-256 validation

13-artifact trust-state baseline validation

current SHA-256 and file-size comparison

change classification

unchanged / reverification required / eligibility invalidated / fail_closed

Current Verified State

これは、Stage377の完了を待ちながらも、 Stage383までの信頼状態と13個の監視対象に 新しい変更や不整合がないことを検証した状態です。

Change Decisions

Verified GitHub Actions State

Stage383 Recovery Session Binding

stage383-66bce0a526782ef0e49221e70bcc939268f0d04e6e2e86e34aea9aed6caf5505

Public Stage384 Evidence

Formal-Acceptance Boundary

Stage384は、監視対象に変更がないことを確認しますが、 Stage377の未完了状態を完成へ変換せず、 正式承認や証明書を発行しません。

Preservation Boundary

Stage384は、Stage377からStage383までの既存記録を 変更、削除、置換、上書きしません。

Publication Boundary

License: MIT License

Stage385: Cryptographic Agility Inventory, PQC Migration Readiness & Algorithm Policy Enforcement Gate

Stage385は、Stage384の継続的信頼状態検証を保持したまま、 暗号方式、公開パラメータ、PQC移行状態、 検証証拠の可搬性を整理・検証します。

Current Verified State

Cryptographic Inventory

PQC Migration State

ML-DSA-65の実行検証証拠は存在しますが、 現在のStage385リポジトリには独立再検証用の ML-DSA公開鍵ファイルが存在しません。 したがって、履歴上の実行検証と 現在の第三者独立再検証可能性を区別します。

Current Migration Gaps

Portable Verification Evidence

Stage385の検証証拠参照は、 Git管理され第三者が取得可能な公開証拠だけに限定されています。 ローカル専用のStage375およびStage377 workflowへの依存は除去され、 Mac、tracked-only clean checkout、 GitHub Actionsで同一の決定論的結果を確認しています。

Verified GitHub Actions State

SHA-256 State

Public Stage385 Evidence

Formal-Acceptance Boundary

Stage385は暗号移行準備性を評価しますが、 Stage377の未完了状態を完成へ変更せず、 正式承認証明書を自動発行しません。

Preservation Boundary

Stage385は、Stage377からStage384までの既存記録を 変更、削除、置換、上書きしません。

Publication Boundary

License: MIT License

Stage386: PQC Independent Re-verification, Public Key Binding & Evidence Portability Gate

Stage386は、Stage385までの暗号移行評価を保持したまま、 Stage375で実際に使用されたML-DSA-65公開鍵を 同一性確認した上で公開証拠へ結合し、 第三者による独立再検証可能性を確立します。

Current Verified State

Stage385 to Stage386 Evolution

Stage385では、ML-DSA-65の過去の実行検証証拠は確認できましたが、 現在のリポジトリから第三者が取得できる ML-DSA公開鍵が存在しないため、 独立した暗号学的再検証は完結していませんでした。

Stage386では、Stage375で実際に使用された公開鍵を 新規生成や置換を行わず復元し、 記録済みPEMおよびDER SHA-256との一致を確認した上で、 署名、署名対象、実行receiptへ結合しました。

Public Key Binding

Independent Re-verification

Stage386は、公開されたML-DSA-65公開鍵、 Stage375署名、署名対象、実行receiptを用いて、 現在の環境から独立したML-DSA-65署名検証を実行します。 公開鍵、署名、対象、アルゴリズム、contextの いずれかが一致しない場合はFail-Closedで拒否します。

Fail-Closed Verification

Public Stage386 Evidence

Verified GitHub Actions State

Formal-Acceptance Boundary

Stage386のPQC独立再検証成功は、 QSPシステム全体が量子安全であること、 Stage377の二重タイムスタンプ最終承認が完了したこと、 またはシステム全体の正式承認が完了したことを意味しません。

Preservation Boundary

Stage386はStage385以前の既存記録を 変更、削除、置換、上書きしません。 Stage385の Current public ML-DSA key available: false はStage385時点の歴史的状態として保持されます。

Publication Boundary

License: MIT License

Stage387: PQC Multi-Implementation Interoperability & Verifier Independence Gate

Stage387は、Stage386で確立した ML-DSA-65の第三者独立再検証可能性をさらに拡張し、 同一証拠を異なる暗号実装でも検証できることを確認します。

Current Verified State

Stage386 to Stage387 Evolution

Stage386では、Stage375で実際に使用された ML-DSA-65公開鍵を復元・同一性確認し、 公開証拠だけを用いた第三者独立再検証を確立しました。

Stage387では、その同じ公開鍵、署名、署名対象、 contextをOpenSSLとCloudflare CIRCLという 異なる暗号実装へ入力し、 両方が同じ検証結果を返すことを確認します。

これにより、 「特定のライブラリだけでは成功するが、 別実装では検証できない」という 実装依存リスクを低減します。

Multi-Implementation Verification

Evidence Binding

Fail-Closed Verification

Evidence Portability

Stage387は15個の検証アーティファクトを deterministic portability manifestへ結合します。 policy、検証器、CIRCL verifier、依存関係、 Fail-Closed test、検証result、Stage375公開証拠、 manifest generator、GitHub Actions workflowまで SHA-256で識別します。

Public Stage387 Evidence

Verified GitHub Actions State

上記baseline runでは、 OpenSSLとCIRCLによるML-DSA-65検証、 相互実装結果一致、Fail-Closed test、 deterministic result、 portability artifact bindingが成功しています。

Formal-Acceptance Boundary

Stage387の相互運用検証成功は、 QSPシステム全体が量子安全であること、 Stage377の二重タイムスタンプ最終承認が完了したこと、 またはシステム全体の正式承認が完了したことを意味しません。

Preservation Boundary

Stage387はStage386以前の既存記録を 変更、削除、置換、上書きしません。 Stage386の独立再検証結果は歴史的記録として保持します。

Publication Boundary

License: MIT License

Stage388: Independent Assessment Readiness & Evidence Package Gate

Stage388は、Stage387で確立した PQC Multi-Implementation Interoperabilityと Verifier Independenceの検証結果を変更せず、 第三者が独立して評価できる決定論的な 証拠パッケージへ整理するステージです。

Stage387 to Stage388 Evolution

Stage387では、同一のML-DSA-65公開証拠を OpenSSLとCloudflare CIRCLの複数実装で検証し、 特定の検証器だけに依存しないことを確認しました。

Stage388では、その検証結果そのものを変更せず、 外部研究者、OSSセキュリティコミュニティ、 セキュリティ専門家が評価するために必要な assessment scope、threat model、trust boundaries、 guarantees、non-guarantees、known limitations、 test matrix、provenanceを明示します。

Current Decision

independent_assessment_evidence_package_ready

このdecisionは、 「第三者評価用証拠パッケージの準備が整った」 ことだけを意味します。

外部評価完了、正式認証、 システム全体の正式承認、 QSP全体の量子安全性を意味しません。

Mandatory Non-Claim State

Fail-Closed Negative Verification

Stage388では、正常系だけでなく、 以下の異常を意図的に発生させ、 Fail-Closedで拒否することを確認しています。

  1. Stage387 result tampering
  2. Required evidence missing
  3. Stage387 SHA-256 mismatch
  4. Private material publication
  5. Unauthorized external-assessment completion claim
  6. Unauthorized formal-certification claim
  7. Unauthorized system-wide acceptance claim
  8. Unauthorized entire-system quantum-safe claim
  9. Stage387 source-commit mismatch
  10. Unauthorized success-decision promotion

Deterministic Evidence Package

Stage388の証拠パッケージは、 明示的なallowlistとSHA-256 bindingを用いて 決定論的に生成・再検証されます。

Canonical package hashは、 自己参照による循環を避けるため このHTMLへ直接埋め込まず、 以下のEvidence Manifestを正本として参照します。

Public Stage388 Evidence

Stage389 External Timestamp Boundary

Stage388では、 RFC3161およびOpenTimestampsによる canonical packageの外部時間固定を実施済みとは主張しません。

Stage389では、 Stage388の最終canonical package hashを対象として RFC3161とOpenTimestampsの二重外部アンカーを Fail-Closedで検証する予定です。

Preservation Boundary

Stage388はStage387以前の検証結果、 公開ページ、公開証拠を削除、置換、 上書きしません。

Publication Boundary

License: MIT License

Stage389: Independent Assessment Package Dual External Timestamp Anchoring & Verification Gate

Stage389は、Stage388で固定された 第三者評価用Evidence Manifestを対象として、 RFC3161とOpenTimestampsによる 二重外部時間アンカーを検証するステージです。

Stage388のcanonical evidence、 canonical package hash、 entry count、source commitは変更せず、 2種類のtimestamp mechanismが 同一のStage388 Evidence Manifestを参照することを Fail-Closedで要求します。

Stage388 Timestamp Subject

Current Decision

dual_timestamp_pending

このdecisionは、 二重外部タイムスタンプの最終検証が まだ完了していないことを意味します。

Stage389は未確認状態を 成功へ昇格させません。

RFC3161 Verification

OpenTimestamps Verification

OpenTimestamps proofが存在することと、 Bitcoin blockchainによる最終検証が完了したことは 同じ意味ではありません。

Stage389は、ローカルBitcoin検証環境に 必要なチェーンデータが存在しない状態を cryptographic successとして扱いません。

Dual Timestamp State

成功decision: independent_assessment_package_dual_timestamp_verified

は、RFC3161とOpenTimestampsの両方が 同一のStage388 Evidence Manifestに対して 独立に検証成功した場合にのみ発行できます。

Deterministic External Verification

Stage389は外部ツールのraw実行出力と、 security-relevantな決定論的状態を分離しています。

RFC3161とOpenTimestampsについて semantic verification fingerprintを生成し、 temporary path、runtime text、 Bitcoin node synchronization progressなどの 実行環境依存文字列がcanonical resultを 不必要に変化させないようにしています。

同一security stateでの複数回検証において、 non-empty JSON resultのbyte-for-byte一致を 確認しています。

Fail-Closed Negative Verification

Stage389では10件のnegative regression testを実行し、 false successを拒否することを確認しています。

  1. Forged Boolean evidence cannot succeed
  2. Stage388 manifest tampering is rejected
  3. Timestamp subject hash tampering is rejected
  4. Canonical package hash tampering is rejected
  5. Stage388 entry-count tampering is rejected
  6. RFC3161 subject mismatch is rejected
  7. OpenTimestamps subject mismatch is rejected
  8. Source-stage tampering is rejected
  9. Missing required evidence is rejected
  10. Pending or incomplete proof cannot promote success

Current regression result: 10 / 10 PASS

Mandatory Non-Claim State

Public Stage389 Evidence

Preservation Boundary

Stage389はStage388以前の検証結果、 公開ページ、公開証拠を削除、置換、 上書きしません。

Publication Boundary

License: MIT License

Stage390: Independent Third-Party Reproduction & Assessment Intake Gate

第三者独立再現・外部評価受入ゲート

Stage390は、Stage389までに固定された検証結果を変更せず、 外部の第三者が独立した再現結果と評価結果を提出し、 QSP側の結果とのagreement、disagreement、 またはincompleteをFail-Closedで判定するための assessment intake interfaceを追加します。

Stage390は第三者評価が完了したことを 自己申告しません。 現在の状態は、第三者評価を受け入れるための interfaceと検証条件が準備された状態です。

Current Decision

third_party_assessment_ready

Independent Assessment State

Stage389 Preservation

Stage390はStage389のtimestamp状態を 成功へ昇格させません。

Bitcoin側の必要なチェーンデータが利用可能になり、 OpenTimestamps検証が成功するまでは、 Stage389自身が dual_timestamp_pending を保持します。

Exact Upstream Binding

Stage390のassessment intakeは、 Stage389の固定されたcanonical resultと source commitへの一致を要求します。 上流証拠の改変や別結果への差し替えは assessment successとして受理されません。

Fail-Closed Third-Party Intake

Stage390では12件のnegative regression testを実行し、 false、malformed、または自己昇格された third-party assessment claimを拒否することを 確認しています。

  1. Forged external assessment completion is rejected
  2. Forged formal certification is rejected
  3. Stage389 result SHA tampering is rejected
  4. Stage389 commit tampering is rejected
  5. Missing independence declaration is rejected
  6. Invalid execution mode is rejected
  7. Incomplete reproduction cannot claim agreement
  8. Zero-mismatch result cannot claim disagreement
  9. Negative mismatch count is rejected
  10. Boolean mismatch count is rejected
  11. Missing required field is rejected
  12. Malformed JSON is rejected

Current regression result: 12 / 12 PASS

Canonical Stage390 Result

SHA-256: 90f57cfdca45fe7b6f3a150302e22060ce1e6ac46d2ff2b12889ca51e8c8dc4e

Public Stage390 Evidence

Preservation Boundary

Stage390はStage389以前の検証結果、 公開ページ、公開証拠を削除、置換、 または上書きしません。

Publication Boundary

Stage390 License

License: MIT License

Stage391: Independent Third-Party Reproduction Verification & Assessment Adjudication Gate

第三者独立再現検証・外部評価判定ゲート

Stage391は、Stage390で構築された third-party assessment intake interfaceに対し、 実際の第三者Submissionを Fail-Closedで検証・分類する adjudication layerを追加します。

Current Decision

third_party_submission_pending

現在、実際の独立第三者Submissionは まだ受領・検証されていません。

Stage390 Binding

Stage391はStage390のcanonical resultを 変更せずに参照します。

Stage389 Preservation

Stage391はStage389のOpenTimestamps状態を 自己昇格させません。

Independent Third-Party Requirement

外部評価として認められるSubmission originは、 independent_third_party のみです。

self-test、smoke-test、developer fixture、 internal CIは外部第三者評価として扱われません。

Adjudication Outcomes

現在、上記の実第三者判定はいずれも authoritative stateとして発行されていません。

Fail-Closed Regression

Negative regression: 16 / 16 PASS

Classification-path fixtures: 3 / 3 PASS

3件のclassification fixtureは agreement、disagreement、incompleteの 分類ロジックを確認するテストデータであり、 実際の外部第三者評価ではありません。

Canonical Stage391 Result

SHA-256: ed644d11bd49f67f89cfda50364d619066b4da3a36bf1fb26b38e111b6092b23

Public Stage391 Evidence

Mandatory Non-Claims

Preservation Boundary

Stage391はStage390、Stage389、 およびそれ以前のcanonical evidence、 公開ページ、検証結果を 削除・置換・上書きしません。

Publication Boundary

Stage391 License

License: MIT License